6/23/2012

UPDATE: Edited for formatting and to change "brokeback" to "broke back."
Recently, there's been an outcry over the cover for Catwoman #0. Drawn by Guillem March, it's a classic example of the "broke back," an anatomically incorrect pose often used in comics to show the boobs and butt at the same time.


When we ran an article on the ten worst brokeback poses, some people questioned whether they were anatomically inaccurate. Fortunately, there are plenty of real artists who are all too happy to illustrate the point. 


Here's some artwork featured at Comics Alliance

First, a side-by-side comparison by Kate Beaton that shows the original cover and a side view.


Cameron Stewart, an artist who once drew Catwoman, also created this artwork with a little more detail on what the side view would be like.

Giaaeron

Giaaeron used computer modeling to show what she would actually look like from this perspective without a broken back with these comments on the original: "The pose, specifically the relationship of butt to bosom. The right arm placement, which is impossible without dislocating her shoulder. Her head placement can’t be duplicated. If you look at Figure 3, you’l notice that the curve of her back is already incredibly pronounced, even in this truncated pose."

Do these illustrations explain the problem with the brokeback pose? What do you think of the new Catwoman cover?
[Image Source: Comics Alliance]

Related Posts

8 comments:

Tony Laplume, Sith Architect said...

I'm thinking that artists will think twice about doing the brokeback, after this one got so much attention.

sqt said...

I'm amazed that these covers are still being made- it's just so ridiculous.

Colin "Fitz" Biggs said...

I'm hoping these will go away. Soon.

Nigel Mitchell said...

I agree. This needs to stop.

Nigel Mitchell said...

You'd think so, but they keep on coming

Nigel Mitchell said...

One can only hope

Jeffrey Crosbie said...

these camera shots made with poser are complete rubbish. they are at different camera angles and are only used to add fuel to the fire of someone who dislikes the new Catwoman comic. I personally like the new comic and am a fan of the sexualized cat woman. How about if someone wants to use a 3d rendering program to show how cat woman would look, that use the opacity on the program and render the drawing of cat woman over it and then we will have a true comparison. If one looks at the angle of the arm and the placement of the knee on the 3d image one would notice that it is very much lower than the cover art. also the camera that took the picture is at a completely different angle in the 3d photo than in the cover art. if one wants to bash and flame on the cover art, and heaven only knows why art is art and for some reason Jackson Pollack is still famous for dripping paint on a canvas, then at least take the extra effort and line up your shots.

Barbara Senna said...

HOW MY HUSBAND FINALLY CAME BACK TO ME !!!

Hello everyone , I am Barbara Senna and i am united states....In the past ,I was in a long term relationship that suppose to lead to marriage but one day came that my fiance lost interest in me because another woman was enticing him with money and fake love.i complained to a friend of mine about what my situation was and she gave me an advice that I contact a powerful spell Caster (eminikokorospiritualhelp@hotmail.com) . At first, i was lackadaisical contacting him but one faithful day, I took a bold step and i contacted him and he replied saying he would help me.. to cut the long story short,he caste a spell and my husband came back to me within 3 days..it was just a surprise to me as I never believed my husband would come back begging for forgiveness. Afterwards we go married, we just came back from honey moon some few days back.. here i am today testifying happily...I said to myself that I would share this to the world if my problem becomes a thing of the past..now I am happy and I am happy sharing it on here happily to all my friends.. so I urge any one who have problems of any kind be it any of these;
if you want your ex back? if you want to bind your husband with you forever?if you want to be cured of Cancer? if you want to be cured of HIV/AIDS? if you disabled?if you want to be prosperous? if you want to have increase in finance? if you want favor and goodluck? if you want to lose weight? if you want to gain weight?if you are barren and you want to have a child? If some who owes you and dont want to pay you back? if you want to be rich and lot more?

contact him now.His email address: eminikokorospiritualhelp@hotmail.com

AddThis

Subscribe to RSS Feed Follow me on Twitter!